The Correct Tesla Bifilar Coil
by
James L Kistner Jr

The bifilar, or two wire, wound coil has found many uses and has become very popular lately in applications ranging from the separation of end products from biodiesel to the all popular 'Tesla Coil' (which should not really be described as such but that is not the purpose of this paper). Most of the time the experimenter winding these bifilar coils is under the impression that he/she is winding what is known as a 'Tesla Bifilar Coil' while that is not really the case. Much of the information and instructions for the winding of these coils is not what is described in Tesla's Patent #512340, "Coil for Electro-Magnets". The illustrations below will illustrate the difference between the winding that is being distributed on the internet and the winding that is specified in the Patent (you'll just have to excuse my drawings, I am not an artist).
First, let's look at the two coils as they are assembled and then drawn out into their two wire lengths:


As you can see, the one one the left (distributed on the 'net) is very different from the one on the right, which is the one specified in Tesla's Patent. Does it really make a difference, though? Does it matter which way the bifilar is wound? Tesla thought so and made some pretty nice claims for the coil he patented. If we examine the flow of current in the wire of the coil, it will give a better picture as to why he made these claims. Below is the current flow for the popular 'internet' bifilar coil:


We see opposing current flow in adjacent wires. Compare this to the current flow in Tesla's coil:


Here we have no opposing flow. All current flow is augmented by the adjacent wires, resulting in an increased magnetic field, just as he said. This has recently been demonstrated by an expeimenter who graciously shared his test of the Tesla Coil against a serially wound coil. If it is still available for viewing it can be seen at the link to the video below. Once you see this video, you will probably never wind a bifilar the 'internet' way again.

1/27/2010
aka Hermit53

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mvb39SwTXBE

Views: 3225

Comment

You need to be a member of HODINFO to add comments!

Join HODINFO


HODINFO SPONSOR
Comment by julian webb on January 29, 2013 at 1:58pm

Hi, has anyone wound (or thought of winding) a 1:1 air core transformer (forgetting efficiencies etc for now) with the first winding/layer a "Tesla" bifilar primary with a "net" winding/layer on top as the secondary? Just theorising for a minute, would this see a primary pumping out a great magnetic field into a secondary that was virtually invisible to the primary? The secondary would extract energy from the primary without altering it's inductance or anything else? Would the "net" bifilar actually be better at extracting energy that a "normal" winding? Any educated or even off-the-top-of-the-head guesses would be appreciated.

Comment by Gary on July 26, 2010 at 8:21am
Looks to me like if you had one flat coil over another, wired in reverse, it would do the same as the tesla coil, since it's current direction that is creating the emf between wire pairs.
Therefore, the next experiment would be to use x amount of wire to create that with 2 flat coils, vs the same amount of wire in a tesla. I would imagine that you'd be creating a tesla coil this way by dividing the flat coil into 2 and reversing current in one.
Comment by Hermit on July 26, 2010 at 7:38am
Well, Robin, I have wound a coils in the 'Tesla ' patent fashion and did experience just what he said I would..VERY poor induced electricity but very GOOD induction to other coils, etc. As you correctly stated (in you own way) each coil has its own applications, and I believe the 'Tesla Patent' wound coil would be a very good application to pulse systems due to its very small back emf factor (unlike most other coils). The experimenters of the Joule Thief circuit came very close to trying this coil (and had fantastic results) but haven;t as far as I know (my info is of about 7 months ago).
And I would love to test coils for you but, I have only a VOM meter and my calculatons. I don't own one of those (coveted) meters that test the capacitance and inductance :( I have plenty of time, not much energy (and that is very sporadic), but a mind that won't leave me alone :)
Comment by Robin S Hooper on July 25, 2010 at 3:33am
My understand in this is then confirmed, Thanks Hermit. What interestes me is that if you use the right hand rule to indicate the b field direction by way of you finger direction. In the internet wound coil b-field flows into both wires from the outside to the inside and in Teslas' coil one wire flows from the outside to the inside and the other wire parallel to it flows from the inside to the outside. Now this is asumming that the b-field has a circular direction as it flows. In short the internets version flow meshes and Teslas flow into each other. Now thats not to say one is better in design than the other, Teslas' bifiar wind will produce a much stronger b-field. Interesting though. Oh, the video provided, thanks by the way, compares a standardly wound coil with Teslas'. The comparison above how ever does not, but the result are still the same or would it be? Hum, Does any one have the time and the resourses to test the three types? I'm afraid I don't. I have all the wire I need but no instrumentation. Hope I've stimulated some of you. I'll wind, ship to you, you test.
Comment by Mike Hingle on May 24, 2010 at 11:05am
Excellent post ! Short, thorough & to the point.
Thank you.
Comment by skysabre on January 31, 2010 at 7:39am
Thanks for this, Hermit. Thank you very much. This clears out a lot of confusion and disappointments.
Comment by Slaven on January 30, 2010 at 5:18pm
Thanks for this info
Comment by gabet123 on January 29, 2010 at 6:23am
I embeded it for you. Thank you or bringing this to our attention.

Translate HODINFO

H2 Energy.gov Feed

ARPA-E Awards $33 Million for New Fuel Cell Projects

The Energy Department's Advanced Research Projects Agency-Energy (ARPA-E) announced $33 million in funding for 13 new projects aimed at developing transformational fuel cell technologies for low-cost distributed power generation.

Latest Activity

Profile IconHydrogen Fuel News » Hydrogen Fuel Cell

Ballard to deliver new hydrogen fuel system for next generation clean bus

 Share on Tumblr  New fuel cell system to be supplied to New Flyer Industries Ballard…

See More
12 hours ago
Profile IconHydrogen Fuel News » Hydrogen Fuel Cell

Mercedes-Benz plans to make its hydrogen fuel cell vehicle cost competitive

 Share on Tumblr  German automaker aims to have its fuel cell vehicle cost as much as…

See More
14 hours ago
Profile IconHydrogen Fuel News » Hydrogen Fuel Cell

New molecule could help solve problems with hydrogen fuel infrastructure

 Share on Tumblr  Scientists discover new molecule that could have a major impact on…

See More
16 hours ago
Profile IconHydrogen Fuel News » Hydrogen Fuel Cell

New hydrogen fuel standard published by SAE International

 Share on Tumblr  SAE International publishes J2601 standard that could help the…

See More
18 hours ago
vuk vlahovic commented on Evgeni Atanasov's video
19 hours ago
Daniel Donatelli Secure Supplies posted a status
"Diesel converted to 100% Hydrogen http://youtu.be/2kknM-ThDlc"
19 hours ago
Daniel Donatelli Secure Supplies posted a status
"Moving and shaking http://youtu.be/ypSeN_T3fA8"
19 hours ago
vuk vlahovic commented on tan kusuma's video
19 hours ago
Profile IconHydrogen Cars and Vehicles Blog

Japan Says All Ministries Must Use Fuel Cell Vehicles

On Friday, 07/25/2014, in Japan, Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshihide Suga had stated that all… See More
yesterday
Profile IconHydrogen Fuel News » Hydrogen Fuel Cell

GE to build facility in Malta to build and test fuel cells

 Share on Tumblr  GE Fuel Cells will be building a new pilot facility in Malta General…

See More
yesterday
Wouter Termote is now a member of HODINFO
yesterday
Profile IconHydrogen Fuel News » Hydrogen Fuel Cell

New funding will help California build 28 hydrogen fuel stations

 Share on Tumblr  California continues to build up its hydrogen infrastructure in…

See More
yesterday

© 2014   Created by gabet123.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service

Live Chat